In south India 's
shattered coastal communities, tsunami survivors are just
beginning to pick up the pieces of their lives. Psychological
trauma is common, but India 's new army of support workers is
providing solace, counselling, and encouragement. - Patralekha
Chatterjee reports.
More than 2 months after the sea swallowed
her husband and destroyed her home, Chellamma sits quietly, thinking
about the future for her three unmarried daughters. The 50 year-old
widow and mother of seven from Muzhukuthurai, in tsunami-battered
Cuddalore, Tamil Nadu, southern India , is only now starting to pick
up the pieces of her life. "I used to sell fish. Now, there is
nothing to sell, [because] no one is going to sea . . . My husband
is gone. Who will look after my children and me?", she asks.
All around is sand, a torn fishing net, and the
remains of a thatched hut--once her home. But there is a glimmer of
hope. Chellamma is one of 20 women in and around Muzhukuthurai who
have formed a self-help group. The first step is a savings kitty,
with each woman contributing Rs50 (around US$1). The savings, the
women hope, will help them start income-generating enterprises and
cope with future emergencies. The idea came from efforts by
community-level workers recently trained in psychosocial counselling.
Psychosocial care can be just as valuable as
material assistance in disaster situations. And there is growing
evidence to show that early diagnosis and timely interventions can
make a significant difference to the recovery process. But few
people who have experienced natural disasters view themselves as in
need of mental health care, and are therefore unlikely to seek help.
To help address the unique needs of such individuals, WHO recommends
that health workers set aside traditional methods, avoid use of
mental health labels, and use an active outreach approach.
In India , psychosocial care has changed a great
deal since the Bhopal Gas Leak tragedy in December 1984. This
disaster--the worst industrial disaster ever seen--left not only a
trail of death and life-long illnesses, but also numerous mental
disorders among survivors. Mental health workers were slow to
respond, however: it was 6-8 weeks before psychiatrists became
involved in the relief effort, a delay attributed to the fact that
none of the five regional medical colleges had a psychiatrist on
their faculty.
By contrast, psychosocial care was a key
concern for local and national government immediately after the
tsunamis hit India in Dec 2004. One reason the situation is so
different from that seen 20 years ago is the new generation of
politicians. In Cuddalore, for example, Gagandeep Singh Bedi,
Cuddalore district's top government administrator admits that the
"young generation of bureaucrats" like him are more responsive to
new ideas. In Bedi's district, the Department of Medical and Rural
Health Services and Family Welfare brings out a daily report about
mental-health outreach sessions in different areas.
| Chellamma and her granddaughter speak
to psychiatric social worker Koteshwar Rao |
| Patralekha Chatterje |
V Sabeetha, a government psychiatrist who
is overseeing mental-health outreach in the district says
counselling services are gratefully received. "My team and I have
held counselling sessions in relief camps in all the 52 villages in
the district . . . Most people we met appreciated being counselled
on typical symptoms following any disaster--eg, sleep disorders,
nightmares, etc. No one had alerted them earlier about these
symptoms", he says.
These sessions helped abate disaster stress in
the early days. But with most people now back in their villages, the
big issue is follow-up, says Sabeetha.
Gauri, a community worker trained in psychosocial
counselling by CREED, a local NGO affiliated with the Tamil Nadu
Social Welfare Board, is trying to reintroduce some semblance of
normality to the people of Muzhukuthurai.
He says active listening was the most valuable
intervention immediately after the tsunamis. "We did not push
[survivors] to speak if they did not want to. But we would ask them
if they had eaten or bathed . . . With the man, the family
breadwinner, gone, and with children to support, widows were nervous
about the new, unfamiliar roles they had been pushed into."
Many whose homes were destroyed have been
allotted temporary sheds. But most families prefer to stay with
relatives. The women cook together and after the meal they sit
around talking to each other. In many ways, the community bond
compensates for the loss of the family support structure, explains
Gauri.
"Though counselling is very important, we
must be careful about not overdoing it. When we find someone can
cope, then we have no role", says Koteshwar Rao, a psychiatric
social worker with the Chennai-based Schizophrenia Research
Foundation (SCARF), one of several agencies offering training in
mental-health counselling for southern India.
Many of the psychosocial interventions being used
were instigated by the WHO regional office. "Within 2 weeks of the
tsunamis, WHO alerted medical schools and WHO collaborating centres.
A group of people were identified to act as master trainers. Then,
talks were initiated with the state governments to drive the return
to normalcy and mental health", says WHO official Cherian Varghese.
He says the idea was to operate on a three-tier structure consisting
of master trainers who would train local NGOs, and trainers at the
district level who would, in turn, train community-level workers.
"The primary need is not an overmedicalised
approach. What most survivors need is empathetic listening and
someone to show them a roadmap to the future", he adds.
A typical psychosocial counselling training
session for NGOs and community volunteers, for instance, contains a
lot of practical tools with which community level workers can assist
tsunami survivors. SCARF trainer Koteshwar Rao stresses the
importance of being up to date with latest government schemes and
knowing details of agencies that are providing free services to
tsunami-affected individuals. Other tools include innovative
suggestions about income generation, such as those adopted by
Chellamma and her community.
| Widows like Chellamma have been
encouraged to set up self-help groups |
| Patralekha Chatterje |
Given that most of those who come for
training know little about mental-health counselling, the sessions
are designed to be entertaining and interactive, with lots of games
and opportunities to express ones creativity and concern. Most
trainees also need a briefing about common symptoms of
post-traumatic stress disorder and basic dos and don'ts of
psychosocial counselling. "The idea is to expand the choices and
options of the affected community so that they focus on the future",
says Rao.
The Academy for Disaster
Management, Education, Planning, and Training, an NGO helping to
educate community workers, has trained nearly 200 elementary school
teachers in tsunami-affected villages in southern India in providing
psychological first-aid to children. Government school teachers who
have undergone training are now experimenting with new ways of
interacting with their students.
One government school teacher who had failed in
her attempts to get a traumatised 6-year-old boy from a
tsunami-affected village to open up took her class to a nearby
nursery. There, the child's interest was sparked by the plants and
he began to ask questions. Taking the cue, the teacher bought him a
few saplings. Since then, the boy and the teacher discuss the
plants' progress every day and the teacher has been reading stories
about flora and fauna surviving adversity.
For the trainers, much of the work goes beyond
classroom-style sessions. In the past few weeks, SCARF's Rao and his
colleagues have travelled to villages to check whether the new
community counsellors have taken on board the key principles of
emergency psychosocial support. The cascade effect of the three-tier
approach sometimes leads to partial comprehension of key
principles--a Chinese whisper effect.
A key concern is monitoring vulnerable groups in
the affected communities. This means not only children and widows
but also widowers. A case in point is 60-year-old tsunami survivor
Kuppuswamy, who lost his wife and is now a single parent. Unfamiliar
with domestic chores, the distressed man wonders who will cook for
him when he moves out of the relief camp, and about the complexities
of arranging a suitable bride for his 23-year-old son.
Today, the immediate challenge is to extend
counselling services to remote villages and reach those who have
been neglected so far. But in the long-term, the challenge is to
provide adequate mental health care with only small numbers of
mental-health professionals. There are less than 4000 trained
psychiatrists in India , and even fewer clinical psychologists.
Predictably, most are located in major cities. As a result, the
majority of people living in rural areas have virtually no access to
mental-health facilities, so for them recovery is likely to be long
and slow.